1 4

Previously Played With

Vintage + Retro

Toys, Books, Collectables & more

2021 Care Bears Grumpy bear

2021 Care Bears Grumpy bear

Sold out

2021 Care Bears Grumpy bear

$22.99 NZD
$22.99 NZD
Sold out
2016 Care Bears Funshine bear

2016 Care Bears Funshine bear

2016 Care Bears Funshine bear

$27.99 NZD
$27.99 NZD
Care Bears press-o-matic game

Care Bears press-o-matic game

Care Bears press-o-matic game

$27.99 NZD
$27.99 NZD
1 7
View all

New In

View all

Orders packed Mon-Fri.

Orders collected by courier Tuesday and Friday.

Let customers speak for us

from 34 reviews

1994 Playmates Star Trek Deep Space Nine Q

John Anderson
1994 Playmates Star Trek Deep Space Nine Q
Quality, Fast, Fair!

I ordered a bouncy ball from 1997. The ball was in pristine condition and arrived so fast! I'm likely to order from Previously Played With again, when I see something I want or reminisce about. The prices were also very good and fair, but also lower than most other places for retro toys.

Juliane Luamanu
1997 Tomy Pokemon Mew bouncy ball
Pollly pocket

Very happy condition exactly as described and fast delivery

Frances White
1994 Bluebird Polly Pocket Slumber party
making this 80s girl super happy

thank you for the super fast and efficient posting, i love my bew addition to my 80s room. will definately be back. thank you i love it 🌼

Tammy Boroevich
1980s Charmkins Windmill house
CareBears mini figures

Excellent sale thank you! Great communication, easy to use website and fast delivery! I highly recommend.

Holly Field
1980s Care Bears Bedtime Bear posable PVC figure

DreamWorks Toothless mini figure

Evie Hayes
DreamWorks Toothless mini figure
Care bear

Loved the care bear and excited to see what else I can buy from you guys .

Khalani Stowers
1986 Care Bear Cub Cheer Bear
2001 playmates Dam Totally Trolls

Item was sent promptly and arrived in perfect condition as expected. Definitely recommend this business. 10/10

Holly Barbrook
2001 Playmates Dam Totally Trolls Suzie Sweetdream

R.L Stine Goosebumps -Stay out of the Basement book

Rosie Morris
R.L Stine Goosebumps -Stay out of the Basement book
Perfect

Just like the description, thank you!

Jess Young
1984 Lots of Legs - Baby toes
It came from beneath the sink - R L Stine

This was my favorite book out of all of them, just in my opinion

Rosie Morris
R.L Stine Goosebumps - It came from beneath the sink book

The Popples' Pajama party book

Jess Bay
The Popples' Pajama party book

1996 Jurassic Park the lost world Koosh ball

Beck Carr
1996 Jurassic Park the lost world Koosh ball
Cute

I love it , in good condition

Summer Nancarrow
2004 Care Bears Secret bear
puppy surprise!! :3

this store is amazing hehehe i love vintage toys <333 puppy surprise was in very good condition and so was the lovely beanie baby and the little pikachu!! sooo cute thank you so much!!!!

Arabella Wayper
1993 Puppy Suprise hot pink + 1 pup